Donation to 1 yuan was received by 3 yuan’s "handling fee" reporter to investigate the phenomenon that many fundraising platforms charged the donor 3 yuan.
"I just want to help sick patients, and I was overcharged by 3 yuan without paying attention";
"Every time I meet a circle of friends who need to donate, I will donate 5 yuan, but every time I have to donate more 3 yuan, this 3 yuan is for the platform, so I don’t want to donate";
……
Recently, on the social media platform, many netizens complained that they had been overcharged by 3 yuan for "no reason" for donating money on the platform. Take a closer look, it turns out that this 3 yuan is the green medical service fee charged by the platform.
According to a recent investigation, many crowdfunding platforms charge 3 yuan fees. These platforms allow users to choose to check and agree to "pay 3 yuan" fees on the grounds of providing health services, helping the platform to operate and improving the efficiency of payment. Although this option can be unchecked, many netizens said that they would not pay attention if they didn’t look carefully, and they were overcharged by 3 yuan without knowing it.
Experts interviewed said that it is difficult to continue the profit-making business of some crowdfunding platforms, and the fundraising business itself is facing the pressure of "self-hematopoiesis". The construction and support of the platform require the input of manpower and material resources, and a certain proportion of service fees can be charged in consideration of the corresponding costs. However, when the platform collects service fees from fund-raisers and donors, it should ensure the openness and transparency of information according to law, and at the same time, it is not for profit.
10 yuan, who intends to donate money, was detained in 13 yuan
The donor said that he was "forced" to charge.
"I wanted to do my best to help others, but when I clicked Pay, I found that the fundraising platform had to charge a few more dollars." Beijing citizen Talia Liu (pseudonym) told reporters.
Recently, she decided to donate money when she saw a classmate’s family’s ×× fundraising link forwarded in the social group, and clicked on the fundraising link. She subconsciously checked the "Green Medical Service Description/Health Notice", but did not read the content carefully. Afterwards, she found that 3 yuan was overpaid.
"Donation to 10 yuan, but paid 13 yuan. What kind of money is this 3 yuan? Is there a handling fee? Or tax? " Talia Liu didn’t understand the extra dollars.
"Isn’t it a fund-raising platform with 0 handling fee?" After repeated verification, Talia Liu found that the problem was "I have read and agreed" and "Green Medical Service Description/Health Notice" checked by himself. She thought that what she agreed to check was the notification of donation, and the green medical service was a gift. In fact, 3 yuan, who overcharged, bought seven health services such as hospital housekeeper, operation arrangement and remote consultation.
Ma Yue (pseudonym), a Shanghai citizen, had a similar experience. "I usually pay by brushing my face, but I haven’t reacted yet, and the money has been paid out." She also didn’t notice the notice on the fundraising page, and when she saw that the sick child needed to raise money, she clicked on the fundraising link to donate. After discovering that 3 yuan was deducted from the fund-raising platform, she decided to donate to other platforms in the future. "I didn’t willingly pay for this 3 yuan money.".
The reporter found on a third-party complaint platform that there were thousands of complaints about the discrepancy between the amount of donation and the amount of deduction, and most of them claimed that 3 yuan was overcharged by "force".
In this regard, the platform publicly replied: The platform has not charged any service fees, and there is no intention of misleading payment. If you are kind and willing to help the platform continue to operate, please leave the fees for your help. Of course, if you need to refund the fees, please apply for a refund at the WeChat official account-Personal Center-My Donation-Funding Platform.
The platform for checking extra charges beyond the donation amount is not only ×× financing. At the end of 2023, Zhao Xia (pseudonym), a Beijing citizen, donated 10 yuan to a sick child on the fund-raising platform, and the deduction information showed that it was 13 yuan. When donating money, she checked the "User Funding Description", but did not read the specific content carefully. She quit the fundraising page and then clicked enter, only to find that 3 yuan’s "platform support fee" was deducted.
Zhao Xia questioned this: "Although I don’t donate much, I hope that all donations can be used on patients. I understand the cost of platform operation, but can you inform the donors clearly and clearly in advance? Can you tell me the specific proportion and amount of donations? "
There are also cases where the donation amount is less than the platform’s overcharge. The reporter noticed that some netizens said on a third-party complaint platform that they donated money to 1 yuan, but they were deducted from the "handling fee" of 3 yuan.
Repeatedly suggesting the need to support 3 yuan.
I thought it was to confirm the donation before checking it.
In order to further understand the situation, the reporter made an actual donation on the fund. In the fund-raising project for a cancer patient, there is an option at the bottom of the page to ask whether the user has read and agreed to the Green Medical Service Description/Health Notice, with an explanation: "XX has provided free fund-raising services for more than 2 million seriously ill families with financial difficulties, and 3 yuan has received seven health services, including hospital housekeeper, operation arrangement and remote consultation, to solve health problems in an all-round way!"
After the reporter checked the service description, the amount of donation support automatically increased by 3 yuan, that is, 23 yuan will be deducted from 20 yuan, 103 yuan will be deducted from 100 yuan, and even 3 yuan will be deducted from 1 yuan. If the service description is not checked, the deduction amount is consistent with the donation support amount.
The reporter contacted the platform, and the staff of the platform explained: "It may be that you checked the cost of green medical service when you donated money, which led to the inconsistency between the donation amount and the deduction amount." "Green medical service is equivalent to being bought by donors for themselves, not given to fund-raisers."
"Under normal circumstances, I will subconsciously check the service description of’ read and agree’. Because on other platforms, if you don’t check it, you can’t enter the next program. Unexpectedly, if you don’t check it on the XX platform, you can guarantee that you won’t be overcharged. " Talia Liu said.
In this regard, the reporter found 10 netizens who posted on the online platform that the above-mentioned platform allowed donors to "pay more for 3 yuan", and all of them said that they checked the green medical service because they thought it belonged to reading the relevant instructions for confirming donations.
However, the reporter found that the fund-raising link can be opened in the small program application of ×××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××
The above 10 respondents made donations through fundraising links, and most of them said that "few people will open the fundraising platform applet to find someone to donate, usually by clicking on the fundraising link in the circle of friends or social groups".
In addition, the reporter found that there are also two fund-raising platforms that deduct the extra expenses of 3 yuan, which are called "support fees" by the two platforms.
Similar to the fund-raising platform, a fund-raising platform has a "User Funding Description" on the donation page. The platform explained: "×××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××× We hope to get your support to help the platform operate better. "
The User Funding Description of this platform can also be checked or unchecked.
It is worth noting that on this platform, even if "User Funding Instructions" is not checked, after clicking "Confirm Payment", the payment page will pop up to remind netizens again that "I hope to support the platform 3 yuan to help more seriously ill families", and the name of the donated patient will appear again above the pop-up box, and the "OK" box will be colored red. When the user clicks "OK", he will automatically check the user’s financial assistance instructions that he has read and agreed to, and then jump directly to the interface for entering the payment password. Only after clicking "Cancel" again can you make a direct donation, and no longer pay for the "funding platform 3 yuan".
Another platform, also known as "Power Help Platform", provides six value-added health services, including in-patient housekeeper, operation arrangement and remote consultation, to solve your health problems in an all-round way. At the same time, the platform is more efficient in making money, and the charity donation can reach the account designated by the fundraiser-support platform 3 yuan money in the first time.
If you can’t think of this 3 yuan, donors need to click "Cancel" several times before they can donate normally.
The platform can charge fees appropriately.
Some platform tips are not sufficient.
The reporter noticed that some fund-raising platforms will draw a certain fee from the money raised by fund-raisers as the service fee of the platform.
For example, a fund-raising platform has issued an announcement. Due to the continuous investment of the platform in technology research and development, operational services and capital security, the operating cost has gradually increased. The platform service fee is charged according to 6% of the withdrawal amount of a single fund-raising project, and the maximum amount of a single fund-raising project does not exceed 8,000 yuan. In addition, the third-party payment platform will still charge 0.6% of the withdrawal amount as the payment channel fee.
The customer service of another fundraising platform told the reporter that the platform does not charge a service fee for launching a serious illness rescue project, but it needs to pay 0.6% of the service fee for the third-party payment channel.
There is also a fund-raising platform that when a single project is presented, the platform will charge 3% of the donated amount of the project as the platform management fee.
The customer service of the platform told reporters that this is to ensure the stable, healthy and continuous operation of the platform. "The platform collects management fees not for profit, but only to ensure the continuous and healthy operation of the platform to cover part of the operating costs of the platform."
So is it reasonable for the fund-raising platform to charge extra fees from donors?
Chang Sha, a lawyer of Beijing Kyoto Law Firm, analyzed that according to the explanation, operation process and optional forms of ×××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××××
Chang Sha suggested that in order to prevent risks, donors should pay special attention to the prompt terms, exemption clauses and explanations of value-added services of the platform when making payments on the online platform.
According to Zheng Xiang, a professor at the School of Law of Beijing Jiaotong University, if the service quality can be improved through the platform of charging to promote public fundraising, and the donations can be used reasonably according to the wishes of donors, "it is ok to charge fees appropriately".
"However, it is better if the platform can get financial support from other channels, such as investor support, financial subsidies, and the realization of related traffic, so there is no need to charge donors." Zheng Xiang thinks.
In the view of a founder of a domestic fund-raising institution who doesn’t want to be named, the fund-raising platform can charge fees, because it is essentially a market behavior. It is understandable to provide better services and ensure the operation of the platform by charging a certain service fee. "As a commercial organization, if the fund-raising platform itself is required to provide free services and bear corresponding responsibilities, it is itself an unequal relationship between power and responsibility."
According to insiders, fund-raising platforms generally attract traffic and acquire customers with the help of non-profit fund-raising business, and then carry out other businesses of the company based on traffic, such as mutual assistance and insurance, and construct a business model of "fund-raising+mutual assistance+insurance". Profit-making business will feed back non-profit business to a certain extent, and fund-raising itself will generate interest.
The insider believes that in the donation process, some platforms have insufficient tips for users, and users often pay extra "support money" without knowing it. The relevant tips are difficult to identify, and it is difficult for donors to understand the specific composition of paying "donations"; At the same time, some platforms do not provide convenience for donors to understand the flow and use of funds, which has caused donors a certain sense of being cheated and concealed. From the perspective of long-term development, this will affect the credibility of the platform.
"The era of free is over." During the interview, many staff members of relevant fundraising platforms believe that the fees for fundraising platforms will become more and more common in the future.
Ms. Guo, an industry insider who has worked in Beijing, Tianjin and other places for many years, told reporters that in reality, many people often misunderstand online fund-raising activities, regard them as purely public welfare activities, and think that the services they provide are free, ignoring the characteristics of enterprise operation behind them and the costs and inputs behind them.
In Ms. Guo’s view, as a market-oriented online fund-raising platform, it needs to undertake various obligations every day, including fund review, disbursement supervision, follow-up, fund return, etc., so it will inevitably generate various costs, which will inevitably involve practical issues such as market-oriented operation mode, or platform charges. Especially with the widespread use of artificial intelligence and other technologies, it is necessary to invest more in order to better use big data, artificial intelligence and other technologies to improve the ability to identify the authenticity of cases and enhance the ability of risk control.
Information disclosure needs to be transparent enough.
Protecting donors’ right to know according to law
China’s current laws do not prohibit fund-raising platforms from charging fees, but according to the provisions of the charity law, platforms need to protect donors’ right to know.
The interviewed experts believe that it is necessary to formulate a standardized and transparent charging mechanism, and at the same time define the nature of the platform and do a good job in guiding the public. Many interviewees also said that their concern is not the charges themselves, but the opacity and irrationality of the charges.
"From the legal point of view, the platform must not conceal the use of donations. As long as donors want to know, charitable organizations should inform them and should take the initiative to inform them." Zheng Xiang said.
In the eyes of the above-mentioned insiders, information disclosure should be transparent enough. With the donor fully informed, it is the donor’s choice whether to donate or not and how much to donate. The page design of the platform can be more optimized, and the payment page can be made more specific and clear by technical means, so as to provide the public with choices, such as checking the options or not, and the change of the amount should be obvious. The platform should also provide more specific explanations for the reasons for the change in the amount.
Jin Jinping, director of the Research Center for Non-profit Organization Law of Peking University Law School, said at the round-table interview seminar on "Ways and Regulations of Serious Illness Fund-raising Platform under the Background of Revision of Charity Law" held in November 2023 that it is necessary for the platform to realize cost sharing by charging a certain fee for sustainable development, but such a premise is that it cannot be for profit.
So, how to determine the standard of service fee? Some experts believe that if necessary, through in-depth research, we can carry out surveys on cost composition and service value, listen to the opinions of users, platforms and relevant parties, and balance the commercial nature of fundraising platforms with the quasi-public nature of service areas.
Zheng Xiang’s view is that charitable organizations charge fees on their own websites, so long as they improve the service quality and encourage more people to donate, "they should be allowed to make their own decisions".
The founder of a fund-raising institution mentioned above said that the setting of service fees is a market behavior, and there is a competitive relationship among various fund-raising platforms. If the service fee of the platform is too high, it can neither meet the public’s expectations nor provide quality services, then the public will naturally abandon the platform and choose other donation platforms. Therefore, the standard of service fee should be adjusted by the market.
"There must be a process of transformation from free to paid." The above-mentioned founders said that when the fundraising platform starts to charge, it will inevitably go through a painful period, and it is necessary to constantly explain to the public why it is necessary to charge. However, if the platform can reach a consensus with the public that fees are charged to provide better services and assume clearer responsibilities, a better donation environment will be formed in the future.
Zheng Xiang said that it is also necessary to establish a post supervision mechanism. For example, if users are not clearly informed of the need to pay fees, the charity authorities of the civil affairs departments will punish them, such as canceling their public fundraising qualifications, so as to form a good donation environment. (Reporter Zhao Li Intern Wan Peng)
Source: Rule of Law Daily
Reporting/feedback